(Reuters Health)—Arthroscopic surgery won’t cure chronic knee pain, locking, clicking, a torn meniscus or other problems related to knee arthritis, according to a panel of international experts.
Every year, more than two million people with degenerative knee problems have arthroscopic surgery.
But guidelines published May 10 in the British Medical Journal recommend against the procedure for just about everyone with knee arthritis.1
“It does more harm than good,” Dr. Reed Siemieniuk, chair of the guideline panel, tells Reuters Health by email. “Most patients experience improvement after arthroscopy, but in many cases, this is probably wrongly attributed to the surgery itself rather than to the natural course of the disease, a placebo effect or [other] interventions, [such as] painkillers and exercise.”
In addition, the procedure is costly—up to $3 billion annually in the U.S. alone—and there’s a risk of rare but serious adverse effects, such as blood clots or infection, says Siemieniuk, who works in the department of Health Research Methods, Evidence and Impact at McMaster University in Hamilton, Ontario, Canada.
The panel, made up of surgeons, physical therapists, clinicians and patients, analyzed data from 13 randomized controlled trials involving a total of 1,668 patients. The trials compared knee arthroscopy with conservative treatments, such as exercise and painkillers.
The panelists also reviewed 12 less-rigorous studies of close to two million patients that looked at complications from the procedure.
After considering the balance of benefits, harms and burdens of knee arthroscopy, as well as the quality of the evidence for each outcome, the panel made a “strong recommendation against arthroscopy.”
The evidence shows a less than 15% probability of “small or very small improvement in short-term pain and function” from the procedure, and improvements would likely last less than a year, the panelists note.
They thought it was more important to avoid postoperative limitations, such as pain, swelling and restricted activity, and the risk of adverse effects.
“Chronic knee pain can be incredibly frustrating to live with—both for the person experiencing the pain and for their doctors,” Siemieniuk says. “The problem is that none of the current options cure the pain. Most people will continue to live with some pain even with weight loss, physical therapy, and painkillers. Knee replacement surgery also has important limitations and should be delayed as long as possible. So it’s no surprise that many placed their hopes in arthroscopic knee surgery.”
Still, he says, “We believe that no one or almost no one would want this surgery if they understand the evidence.”
If you have chronic knee pain, “double down on efforts for things we know work—for example, weight loss and physical therapy,” he advise.
Dr. Joseph Bosco, vice-chair at NYU Langone Orthopedics in New York City, tells Reuters Health, “In general, I agree with the findings and support most of the conclusions.”
“The only issue is that in the study with the strongest evidence, the operative group did not do physical therapy,” he says by email. “That is not consistent with how we treat our patients. Almost all patients get physical therapy following knee arthroscopies.”
“Cortisone injections, physical therapy and anti-inflammatory medications work as well or better than surgery for most degenerative meniscal tears,” says Bosco, who was not involved in developing the guidelines.
However, he adds, a small group of people “who [also] have mechanical symptoms, localized pain and acute onset of pain will benefit, so a blanket recommendation against all surgery for degenerative meniscal tears is not appropriate.”
Reference
- Siemieniuk RAC, Harris IA, Agoritsas T, et al. Arthroscopic surgery for degenerative knee arthritis and meniscal tears: A clinical practice guideline. BMJ. 2017 May 10;357:j1982. doi: 10.1136/bmj.j1982.
